문서의 이전 판입니다!
USB Stick 성능 비교
- 더티테스트 조건은 USB flash memory 특성상 지속쓰기 저하를 체크하기 위해
최대 50GB 까지만 테스트를 진행하였음 - 더티테스트시
FAT32로 되어있을경우 4GB이상 테스트가 불가하므로 반드시exFAT이나NTFS로 포멧후 테스트 해야함 - USB Flash 제품중
SSD형 제품은cache메모리가 별도로 탑재된 제품의 경우전체용량 테스트진행함
벤치마크 테스트 환경은 순정 윈도우 같은 변인요소를 차단한 환경이 아닌 실사용중인 환경에서 다양한 어플리케이션을 수행하면서 동시에 USB허브에 다른 수신기나 블루투스등이 사용중인 상태에서 벤치마크를 수행했으므로 최상의 결과가 아님을 알려드립니다. 반대로 말하면 동일한 제품을 보유하셨다면 최소한 여기에 나온 성능보다는 좋게 나와야 정상입니다.
추천제품은 파란색 으로 표시하였음
| 브랜드 | 제품 | LED | 용량 | 읽기속도 | 쓰기속도 | 더티테스트 평균속도 | USB-C Read | USB-C Write | USB-C 더티테스트 | 구매당시가격 | 주의사항 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sandisk | Cruzer Blade | X | 16 GB | 20 MB/s | 10 MB/s | 5 MB/s | 3,000 | ||||
| Ultra USB3 | O | 64 GB | 150 MB/s | 50 MB/s | 53 MB/s | 9,000 | |||||
| Ultra Flair USB 3.0 | X | 32 GB | 150 MB/s | 35 MB/s | 23 MB/s | 7,000 | |||||
| eVtran | SSD | O | 256 GB | 350 MB/s | 300 MB/s | 326 MB/s | 43,000 | 재생NAND 의심 | |||
| V03S MLC | O | 128 GB | 220 MB/s | 150 MB/s | 139 MB/s | 25,000 | 재생NAND 의심 | ||||
| V03S SLC 3.0 | O | 8GB | 180 MB/s | 110 MB/s | 103 MB/s | 10,000 | 재생NAND 의심 | ||||
| 리뷰안 | UX200 | O | 64 GB | 210 MB/s | 100 MB/s | 97 MB/s | 30,000 | ||||
| UX300 | O | 256GB | 460 MB/s | 280 MB/s | 315 MB/s | 85,000 | |||||
| Orico | UFSD-I | X | 512 GB | 405 MB/s | 350 MB/s | 234 MB/s | 53,000 | ||||
| SONIZOON | PSSD USB3.1 | O | 512 GB | 420 MB/s | 380 MB/s | 361 MB/s | 50,000 | 재생NAND 의심 | |||
| TeamGroup | X1 MAX | X | 512 GB | 435 MB/s | 435 MB/s | 380 MB/s | 1000 MB/s | 1000 MB/s | 624 MB/s | 77,000 | |
| MOVESPEED | SP20 | X | 2TB | 435 MB/s | 435 MB/s | 413 MB/s | 2100 MB/s | 1900 MB/s | 974 MB/s | 135,000 |
알리 익스프레스에서 판매중인 제품들의 대부분은 재생NAND로 의심된다. 수명이 일반적인 유명브랜드제품보다 확연히 떨어지는경우가 많으며 돌연사의 경우가 의외로 많다.
SLC 로 된 제품의 경우는 칩 자체 수명이 길어서 크게 상관이 없는경우가 대부분이지만 MLC/TLC 로 된 제품의 경우는 뽑기운이 있으므로 구매하거나 사용시에 각별히 주의하기 바란다.
USB 제품의 상세정보 내용중 요구 전력양도 상당히 중요한 요소이다. 200mA ~ 1000mA 까지 다양한데 요구 전력양이 클수록 인식이 잘 안되거나 끊기는 경우가 빈번할 수 있다. 고성능 제품의 경우 요구 전력양이 높으므로 메인보드에 직결하는것을 권장하며 연장선을 이용하여 연결하는경우 요구전력양이 작은 제품을 사용하는 것이 좋다.
알리 제품중에 성능은 좋으나 smi_flash_id 프로그램으로 조회시 아래와 같이
Original Spare Block Count : 138
Vendor Marked Bad Block : 0
Bad Block From Pretest : 92
이런 정보가 나오는것으로 보아 재생NAND를 사용하는것이 아닐까 하는 의심이 있다. 확실하지는 않다.
Sandisk Cruzer Blade
16GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(SanDisk Cruzer Blade) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 2.00 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 200mA USB Device ID: VID = 0781 PID = 5567 Serial Number: 2006087721166A538531 Device Vendor: SanDisk Device Name: Cruzer Blade Device Revision: 0201 Manufacturer: SanDisk Product Model: Cruzer Blade Product Revision: 2.01 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
usbdriveinfo
Volume: H: Controller: SanDisk Possible Memory Chip(s): Not available VID: 0781 PID: 5567 Manufacturer: SanDisk Product: Cruzer Blade Query Vendor ID: SanDisk Query Product ID: Cruzer Blade Query Product Revision: 2.01 Physical Disk Capacity: 16008609792 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 15990775808 Bytes Internal Tags: 3Y4F-8CB4 File System: FAT32 Relative Offset: 1024 KB USB Version: 2.00 Declared Power: 200 mA ContMeas ID: 24AC-04-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 26100 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
Sandisk Ultra USB3
64GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(SanDisk Ultra) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 896mA USB Device ID: VID = 0781 PID = 5581 Serial Number: 4C531001520901109171 Device Vendor: SanDisk Device Name: Ultra Device Revision: 0100 Manufacturer: SanDisk Product Model: Ultra Product Revision: 1.00 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
usbdriveinfo
Volume: H: Controller: SanDisk Possible Memory Chip(s): Not available VID: 0781 PID: 5581 Manufacturer: SanDisk Product: Ultra Query Vendor ID: SanDisk Query Product ID: Ultra Query Product Revision: 1.00 Physical Disk Capacity: 62176362496 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 62171119616 Bytes Internal Tags: 3W4F-8CF4 File System: EXFAT Relative Offset: 1024 KB USB Version: 3.00 Declared Power: 896 mA ContMeas ID: 24AC-05-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 26100 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
Sandisk Ultra Flair USB 3.0
32GB
chipgenius
Description: [F:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(USB SanDisk 3.2Gen1) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.20 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 896mA USB Device ID: VID = 0781 PID = 5591 Serial Number: 0101E0FDD0C86576DCF0E14412CCDF0B69FC9647895746B975729694E4F9FAC0D9A100000000000000000000447C8A7E000A0D00915581072A30C8A5 Device Vendor: USB Device Name: SanDisk 3.2Gen1 Device Revision: 0100 Manufacturer: USB Product Model: SanDisk 3.2Gen1 Product Revision: 1.00 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
usbdriveinfo
Volume: F: Controller: SanDisk Possible Memory Chip(s): Not available VID: 0781 PID: 5591 Manufacturer: USB Product: SanDisk 3.2Gen1 Query Vendor ID: USB Query Product ID: SanDisk 3.2Gen1 Query Product Revision: 1.00 Physical Disk Capacity: 30784094208 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 30767300608 Bytes Internal Tags: 3Y4X-QACL File System: FAT32 Relative Offset: 16 KB USB Version: 3.10 Declared Power: 896 mA ContMeas ID: D941-03-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 22631 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
eVtran SSD 256G
256GB
chipgeinus
Description: [J:][K:][L:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(ASMT 2115) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed USB Device ID: VID = 174C PID = 55AA Serial Number: 123456789037 Device Vendor: EVTRAN Device Name: EVTRAN SSD Device Revision: 0100 Manufacturer: ASMT Product Model: 2115 Product Revision: 0 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
벤치결과
eVtran V03S 128G
128GB
chipgeinus
Description: [H:][I:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(eVtran V03S) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 304mA USB Device ID: VID = 1F75 PID = 0903 Serial Number: 000000000000000143 Device Vendor: eVtran Device Name: V03S Device Revision: 0001 Manufacturer: eVtran Product Model: V03S Product Revision: 1.00 Controller Vendor: Innostor Controller Part-Number: IS903-A5 - F/W 1.23.02.00 Flash ID code: 453A95937AD7 - SanDisk SDTNQGBMA-016G - 4CE/Dual Channel [MLC-16K Toggle-DDR] -> Total Capacity = 128GB Tools on web: http://dl.mydigit.net/special/up/innostor.html Possible Flash Part-Number ---------------------------- [1CE]SDTNQGBMA-016G x 4 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels Flash ID mapping table ---------------------------- [Channel 0] [Channel 1] 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7 453A95937AD7
usbdriveinfo
Volume: H: Controller: Innostor IS903 A5 Possible Memory Chip(s): SanDisk SDYNQGDMM-064G *2 Memory Type: MLC Flash ID: 453A9593 7AD7 Flash CE: 4+4 Flash Channels: Dual Chip F/W: 1.23.02.00 VID: 1F75 PID: 0903 Manufacturer: eVtran Product: V03S Query Vendor ID: eVtran Query Product ID: V03S Query Product Revision: 1.00 Physical Disk Capacity: 127818226688 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 127778291712 Bytes Internal Tags: CW3H-QCGL File System: EXFAT Relative Offset: 1024 KB USB Version: 3.00 Declared Power: 304 mA ContMeas ID: 24AC-02-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 26100 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
eVtran V03S SLC 3.0
8GB
chipgeinus
Description: [G:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(eVtran V03S SLC) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 304mA USB Device ID: VID = 1F75 PID = 0903 Serial Number: 1037622903 Device Vendor: eVtran Device Name: V03S SLC Device Revision: 0001 Manufacturer: eVtran Product Model: V03S SLC Product Revision: 1.00 Controller Vendor: Innostor Controller Part-Number: IS903-A5 - F/W 1.01.02.00 Flash ID code: 98D5D02276D5 - Toshiba TH58TVG5S2FTA20 - 2CE/Dual Channel [SLC-8K Toggle-DDR] -> Total Capacity = 8GB Tools on web: http://dl.mydigit.net/special/up/innostor.html Possible Flash Part-Number ---------------------------- [1CE]TC58TVG4S2FTA00 x 2 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels [2CE]TH58TVG5S2FTA20 x 1 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels Flash ID mapping table ---------------------------- [Channel 0] [Channel 1] 98D5D02276D5 98D5D02276D5 98D5D02276D5 98D5D02276D5 -------- -------- -------- --------
usbdriveinfo
Volume: G: Controller: Innostor IS903 A5 Possible Memory Chip(s): Toshiba TH58NVG5S2FTA20 *2 Memory Type: SLC Flash ID: 98D5D022 76D5 Flash CE: 2+2 Flash Channels: Dual Chip F/W: 1.01.02.00 VID: 1F75 PID: 0903 Manufacturer: eVtran Product: V03S SLC Query Vendor ID: eVtran Query Product ID: V03S SLC Query Product Revision: 1.00 Physical Disk Capacity: 8258584576 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 8256483328 Bytes Internal Tags: CXXH-QCH4 File System: NTFS Relative Offset: 1024 KB USB Version: 3.00 Declared Power: 304 mA ContMeas ID: D941-02-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 22631 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
리뷰안 UX200
64GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(RevuAhn MLC USB 3.0) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 304mA USB Device ID: VID = 1F75 PID = 0903 Serial Number: 000000000000000000E9 Device Vendor: RevuAhn Device Name: RevuAhn UX200 Device Revision: 0001 Manufacturer: RevuAhn Product Model: MLC USB 3.0 Product Revision: 1.00 Controller Vendor: Innostor Controller Part-Number: IS903-A5 - F/W 1.23.01.00 Flash ID code: 8988244BA900 - Intel JS29F32B08JAME1 - 4CE/Dual Channel [MLC-8K] -> Total Capacity = 64GB Tools on web: http://dl.mydigit.net/special/up/innostor.html Possible Flash Part-Number ---------------------------- [1CE]JS29F64G08AAME1(25nm) x 4 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels [2CE]JS29F16B08CAME1(25nm) x 2 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels [4CE]JS29F32B08JAME1(25nm) x 1 pcs/Channel x 2 Channels Flash ID mapping table ---------------------------- [Channel 0] [Channel 1] 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900 8988244BA900
usbdriveinfo
Volume: H: Controller: Innostor IS903 A5 Possible Memory Chip(s): Intel 29F32B08JCME2 *2 Intel 29F32B08JCME3 *2 Intel 29F32B16NCME1 *2 Intel 29F32B08JAME1 *2 Memory Type: MLC Flash ID: 8988244B A9 Flash CE: 4+4 Flash Channels: Dual Chip F/W: 1.23.01.00 VID: 1F75 PID: 0903 Manufacturer: RevuAhn Product: RevuAhn UX200 Query Vendor ID: RevuAhn Query Product ID: MLC USB 3.0 Query Product Revision: 1.00 Physical Disk Capacity: 63909113344 Bytes Windows Disk Capacity: 63904415744 Bytes Internal Tags: CY4H-QCDL File System: EXFAT Relative Offset: 1024 KB USB Version: 3.00 Declared Power: 304 mA ContMeas ID: 24AC-03-00 Microsoft Windows 10 x64 Build 26100 ------------------------------------ http://www.antspec.com/usbflashinfo/ Program Version: 9.4.0.645
벤치결과
리뷰안 UX300
256GB
chipgenius
Description: [F:][I:][J:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(ASMT 2115) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.00 Current Speed: High Speed USB Device ID: VID = 174C PID = 1153 Serial Number: 00000000000000000000 Device Vendor: ASMedia Device Name: AS2115 Device Revision: 0001 Manufacturer: ASMT Product Model: 2115 Product Revision: 0 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
벤치결과
Orico UFSD-I
512GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:][I:]USB 대용량 저장 장치(ORICO UFSD-I) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.20 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 896mA USB Device ID: VID = 152D PID = 0562 Serial Number: DD56419884B94 Device Vendor: ORICO Device Name: UFSD-I Device Revision: 0303 Manufacturer: ORICO Product Model: UFSD-I Product Revision: 0303 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
벤치결과
SONIZOON PSSD USB3.1
512GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:]UAS(USB Attached SCSI) 대용량 저장 장치(SONIZOON M.Pssd USB3.1) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.10 Current Speed: High Speed USB Device ID: VID = 174C PID = 55AA Serial Number: MSFT30SEZ223846CM0001183 Device Vendor: SONIZOON Device Name: M.Pssd USB3.1 Device Revision: 0100 Manufacturer: SONIZOON Product Model: M.Pssd USB3.1 Product Revision: 0 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
smiflashid
v0.5681a Drive: 5(USB) OS: 10.0 build 26100 Model: SONIZOON Fw : S0128A Size : 483328 MB [506.8 GB] From smart : [SMI2246XT] [2019-01-28\] Controller : SM2246XT bufferless Bank00: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank01: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank02: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank03: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank04: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank05: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank06: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank07: 0x98,0x3e,0xa6,0x93,0x7e,0xd1,0x8,0x0 - Toshiba 15nm MLC 16k 512Gb/CE 128Gb/die 2Plane/die Bank26: 0x0,0x66,0x68,0x0,0x2,0x0,0x0,0x66 - Bank27: 0x68,0x8,0x0,0x0,0x0,0x66,0x53,0x66 - Bank28: 0x53,0x66,0x55,0x66,0x68,0x0,0x0,0x0 - Bank29: 0x0,0x66,0x68,0x0,0x7c,0x0,0x0,0x66 - Bank30: 0x61,0x68,0x0,0x0,0x7,0xcd,0x1a,0x5a - Bank31: 0x32,0xf6,0xea,0x0,0x7c,0x0,0x0,0xcd - Channel: 4 CE : 2 TotDie : 16 Plane : 4 Die/Ce : 4 Ch map : 0x0F CE map : 0x03 Inter. : 4 First Fblock : 11 Total Fblock : 2126 Total Hblock : 7552 Fblock Per Ce : 1063 Fblock Per Die: 1063 Original Spare Block Count : 138 Vendor Marked Bad Block : 0 Bad Block From Pretest : 92
벤치결과
TeamGroup X1 MAX
512GB
chipgenius
Description: [H:]UAS(USB Attached SCSI) 대용량 저장 장치(General USSD) Device Type: Mass Storage Device Protocal Version: USB 3.20 Current Speed: High Speed Max Current: 896mA USB Device ID: VID = 8644 PID = 10D1 Serial Number: MSFT30AA000000000000000015 Device Vendor: General Device Name: USSD Device Revision: 0100 Manufacturer: General Product Model: USSD Product Revision: 1000 Controller Part-Number: Unknown
벤치결과
MOVESPEED SP20
2TB
USB-A 벤치결과
USB-C 벤치결과
관련 소프트웨어
USB Stick 의 정보를 조회하는 프로그램중에 ChipGenius라는 유명한 프로그램이 있는데, 1225 이후에 나온 버전은 트로이가 내장되어있으니 가급적 사용하지 않기를 바라며 반드시 1225 버전만 사용하는것을 권장한다. 대신 아래 링크의 smiflashid나 usbflashinfo 프로그램을 사용하시기 바랍니다.
하지만 usbdriveinfo 의 경우 SSD기반의 제품은 인식하지 못하는 문제가 있다.